First reported by Reuters February 3, news was interpreted by many as an endorsement by the U.S. government of lunar property rights for private companies. Nield said that was not the intent of the FAA’s review.
Sunday, February 8, 2015
Bigelow, FAA not talking lunar property rights
Friday, November 15, 2013
"The Best of Times, the Worst of Times..."
![]() |
| Robert Bigelow explains his commercial lunar habitat, being readied to undergo a test deployment in the Nevada desert, last May. More recently he's proposed using of the NASA COTS model to explore cislunar space and establish 'extended human activity' on the Moon [Bigelow Aerospace]. |
Parabolic Arc
All the promise, perils and contradictions of America’s human spaceflight effort were on display earlier this week in Washington, D.C.
Things were looking good for a day or so, but then the proverbial other shoe dropped to remind everyone of the deep trouble that lies ahead as NASA attempts to restore its human spaceflight capability and send astronauts beyond low Earth orbit.
As NASA struggles to execute a series of ambitious programs on increasingly tight budgets, the main beneficiary appears to be the bumbling, crisis prone Russian space agency Roscosmos, which has reaped a financial windfall as a result of America’s equally bumbling human spaceflight policy. And matters could get worse before they get better (for NASA, at least).
The events of the week played out as follows:
Bigelow urges use of COTS model for cislunar transportation
Jeff Foust, New Space Journal, November 15, 2013
Tuesday, December 11, 2012
Turning science fiction to science fact: Golden Spike makes plans for human lunar missions
| Golden Spike proposes to land humans on the surface of the Moon commercially as soon as 2020, for a price tag that has raised eyebrows—and some skepticism [Golden Spike Company]. |
The Space Review
The last 12 months has seen the unveiling of a number of commercial space ventures whose audacious plans can’t be immediately dismissed given the technical and financial pedigree of their founders and backers. Almost exactly a year ago, Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen announced the formation of Stratolaunch Systems, an air-launch system that requires the development of the world’s largest airplane. Allen assembled a team that included Scaled Composites and, originally, SpaceX (since replaced by Orbital Sciences), with a board that included Burt Rutan and former NASA administrator Mike Griffin (see “Stratolaunch: SpaceShipThree or Space Goose?”, The Space Review, December 19, 2011). In April, Planetary Resources announced plans for a series of robotic missions to prospect and, eventually, mine asteroids. That company has an impressive list of investors, including Google’s Larry Page and Eric Schmidt as well as Ross Perot Jr. and former Microsoft executive and two-time space tourist Charles Simonyi (see “Planetary Resources believes asteroid mining has come of age”, The Space Review, April 30, 2012).
Yet, the goals of these startups—a giant air-launch system and missions to prospect and mine asteroids—pale in comparison to the goal of another new space startup: sending people to the surface of the Moon. That feat has been accomplished only six times, and by one nation, the United States, with the last such mission, Apollo 17, flying 40 years ago this month. At the time, it was a potent symbol of America’s capabilities, and one of the signature achievements of the 20th century. The scale of that accomplishment, in many respects, grows as the decades stretch on without anyone else repeating it.
Given those factors, the idea that a human landing on the Moon could be done commercially, and for a fraction of the cost of Apollo or any more recent proposal, hardly seems credible. However, like those other firms, the plans of Golden Spike, the company that formally announced last week its desire to carry out such missions starting as soon as 2020, can’t be easily dismissed. The company has assembled an impressive team, including an Apollo veteran and others with experience in technology, science, policy, and finance. But can this lunar A-team overcome what are likely to be giant technical and financial obstacles?
Monday, July 23, 2012
Posey: “Going to the moon should be a goal”
![]() |
| U.S. Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL) attending committee meeting in Washington earlier this year. |
Space Politics
Sunday’s edition of Florida Today features excerpts of an interview with Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL), including some discussion of space policy issues. Posey doesn’t break much new ground here, defending his vote on an appropriations bill that included language calling on NASA to immediately downselect to one or two commercial crew providers. He compares it to building a house on a $100,000 budget: “Do you hire one contractor to build your $100,000 house? Or do you hire four contractors and say, see how far you can go for $25,000 each?”
Wednesday, June 6, 2012
Human space exploration: asteroids vs. the Moon?
![]() |
| Sunflower solar panel-powered architecture, featuring the LER, Athlete and Chariot vehicles, that were well along in development before Congress and the Obama administration shelved the Constellation program [NASA/John Frassanito & Associates]. |
Thursday, April 12, 2012
Staking a claim on the Moon
The Space Review
A long-running cause célèbre of some elements of the space advocacy movement has been the issue of private property rights, or the lack thereof, beyond Earth. Despite the existence of many private ventures that are happy to sell you plots of land on the Moon or other worlds, there are no recognized claims of property on those celestial bodies. The Moon Treaty of 1979, for example, explicitly prohibits any entity, government or commercial, from claiming any territory on the Moon.
While that treaty has been ratified or acceded to by only a handful of countries, the older Outer Space Treaty (OST), widely accepted by all major spacefaring countries, prohibits countries from making any claims of national sovereignty over the Moon or other celestial bodies. Without any nation claiming territory on the Moon, the conventional wisdom goes, there is no national government that can register or recognize claims made by individuals or companies to property there. Changing that situation would require amending the OST, a process that would likely be drawn-out, messy, and unpredictable.
Or does it? A white paper released last week argues that private property claims to territory in outer space could be consistent with the OST, provided the US passed legislation to recognize those claims. Such legislation could enable private entities inside and outside the US to claim property of the Moon, thus enabling greater private development in space. Others, though, while acknowledging the need for private property rights on the Moon, say the loophole that this proposal exploits doesn’t actually exist.
Tuesday, November 8, 2011
TSR: Fear of a Chinese Moon
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Fierce urgency of NOW for US space industry
Jeff Foust
Space Politics
“NASA has a very short period of time to work with Congress and come up with a unified position and get their act together, and let industry know what’s going on,” Jim Maser told reporters in a roundtable Monday in Washington. “We’ve got to pick something, we’ve got to move on.”
Maser said he was concerned about the effect of extended uncertainty about NASA’s future plans on an industry already challenged by low flight rates and an unstable supplier base. He described one specific supplier of a component for the RL-10 rocket engine that still does business with him because the owner “wants to be part of the space business”. That owner, he added, is in his 80s, and his heirs don’t share that passion.
“With this uncertainty I would think there’s a fair number of second- and third-tier suppliers” who are rethinking their commitment to the industry, he warned. “In the absence of a decision in the next four to eight months, I think companies will be making decisions about space.”
Monday, August 9, 2010
Griffin’s critique of NASA’s new direction
Former NASA administrator Mike Griffin was less critical than in months past, speaking to a conference of the International Mars Society in Dayton, Ohio, Friday. The House committee plan for NASA FY2011 , he said, was better than the Senate's, and plans preliminarily approved in both chambers were superior to plans promoted by the White House [File photo: CSM, April 2009].Jeff Foust
The Space Review
Griffin started his speech by first reviewing the administration’s proposed plan for NASA, and his take on it—which, not unexpectedly, wasn’t particularly positive. One area of concern he expressed was the plan by the White House to defer a decision on a heavy-lift vehicle (HLV) to no later than 2015. “I would ask you to note the timing,” Griffin said: a 2015 decision would come near the end of President Obama’s second and final term (assuming he wins reelection in 2012), and thus the funding decisions would be put in the lap of his successor. “By the time there was any budget year that would actually have to support the development of a real heavy-lift rocket, the president who is promising to do it will be gone,” he said.
Monday, February 15, 2010
Augustine: new plan’s means meet the ends
Norm Augustine, chairman of the Review of US Human Spaceflight Plans Committee largely endorsed the Obama administration’s newly proposed direction for NASA, Monday, speaking to a meeting of the American Physical Society in Washington. According to Jeff Foust, Space Politics, Augustine did offer "some caveats and concerns, primarily about funding."Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Richardson speaks out on Commercial Space
New Mexico Governor Bill RichardsonJeff Foust
Space Politics
Yesterday’s rollout of Virgin Galactic’s SpaceShipTwo vehicle featured appearances by two sitting governors: Arnold Schwarzenegger of California and Bill Richardson of New Mexico. However, there wasn’t much in the way of politics at the event other than a brief statement by Richardson, echoing something he said over a year ago:
Thursday, December 3, 2009
Columbia on their minds?
Over north central Texas, February 1, 2003, traveling on the edge of space at Mach 18, the first Space Shuttle Columbia breaks apart during re-entry, killing all seven of her crew and scattering wreckage over thousands of square miles of east Texas, northeast of Houston. Ironically the flawless regularity of the program's final missions following a very restricted return to space, a clear-headed attention to detail and professionalism and (finally) a realistic assessment of what was always an incredible, useful, but inherently dangerous test vehicle has led many outside NASA to again take vehicle safety for granted, the temptation to push the vehicle into its fourth decade of service seems easy. More ironic, the long gap in U.S. manned spaceflight ahead, after the Shuttle's retirement in 2010 (a billion dollar line item, already well underway), is leading to a brain-drain and erosion of institutional memory and experience at every level. More tempting still is to forget how the United States came to be in this position, to allow an institution's mere self-continuity and tradition to become its sole reason-for-being.It would belabor the point to review the Space Shuttle's record, its surprising capabilities, needed more today in no small part because of its 130 missions. And it only seems obvious that the Shuttle never lived up to its primary selling points decades ago, those of convenience, lowered cost and primarily safety, because of those missions since 1981. The Hubble Space Telescope was also a product of that same difficult and clumsy long-term planning so typical of Washington, built to accommodate the two-year election cycle of the U.S. House of Representatives, with its power of the purse.
It's a good idea to look back and to ask how we got here, and to consider America's present dilemma concerning manned spaceflight to be a clear repetition of a similar process that unfolded almost four decades ago, once again in a age-old political dynamic built around short-term planning. In 1971 no one believed a decade would pass before the Space Shuttle flew, or that aside from the surprisingly useful Skylab missions and the Apollo-Soyuz rendezvous in 1975, that first gap in manned spaceflight would last until 1981. The missions underway had NASA's attention, as an institution where lunar travel never lost its novelty.
A similar situation is underway once again, with tight budgets and a host of nested institutions and stockholders prepared to argue over what, in an age where entitlement obligations exceed double the value of all the assets of America and Americans, mere table scraps. A unified vision articulated finally, after the loss of Columbia, is hanging by a thread. And partisan adversaries are squaring off for a bruising fight, each accusing the other of being unrealistic.
Jeff Foust has been following an almost invisible set of congressional hearings, that seemed to suddenly crop up, ostensibly dedicated (once again) to "safety" of one vision of NASA's future over another.
From his writings on his Blog "Space Politics," Jeff offers "A few notes on the human spaceflight hearing," Thursday.
Meanwhile Mark Whittington, writing for the Houston Space News Examiner in "Ares 1 vs.commercial launchers - how to replace the space shuttle?" and points to "Two recent editorials in the journal Space News, one by Congressman Ralph Hall opposing a commercial solution to Earth to low Earth orbit space flight," and "the other by Patti Grace Smith, a former FAA associate administrator" writing for commercial space transportation, and supporting commercial space flight, illustrates development of a new and quite unnecessary controversy in space policy. "
And Keith Cowing for NASA Watch details where prepared statements can be read and the scheduled rebroadcast of the House committee hearings this coming weekend, HERE.
Monday, November 23, 2009
An impatient space community
Space Politics
A few other notes from Alan Ladwig’s talk Friday at the University of Nebraska space law conference in Washington:
Ladwig acknowledged the uncertainty that many have felt over the last year about the future policy direction of the new administration. “The space community has been a little on edge during the past 11 months, waiting to see what the Obama Administration has in store for us,” he said, calling the agency currently a “work in progress.” “The space community is not a patient lot, and we’re not putting up well with the pace, the priority, and the inconvenience of having to wait for the new administration to determine our direction and level of resources committed to the civil space program.”
Some changes might be visible soon, though. Ladwig noted that new administrator Charles Bolden is now free to make organizational changes and realign personnel in the agency now that he’s passed the 120-day mark in his tenure there. “We expect an announcement on that to be coming before Thanksgiving.”
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
"Heavy-Lift yes, EELV no?"
SpacePolitics.com
"While the Augustine committee wraps up its final report, NASA hasn’t been standing still waiting for it. In an article in Monday’s issue of The Space Review, I wrote about Bolden’s statements in his Space Transportation Association speech on Thursday about what NASA’s internal planning:"
"While Bolden didn’t mention any specifics in Washington, he did let slip a few details about what might be included on Monday at the IAC in Daejon, South Korea, Flightglobal.com reports. Bolden was clearly interested in developing a heavy-lift vehicle, saying that NASA was “costing” such a launcher, which the report believes is the Ares 5 “Lite” vehicle mentioned in the Augustine committee report instead of a shuttle-derived alternative or even simply re-estimating the development cost of the Ares 5 itself."
Thursday, August 6, 2009
$50 million for commercial crew development
Space Politics
Monday, June 22, 2009
Definitive story of Augustine Committee meeting, last week
The reason is simple. We knew Jeff Foust of Space Politics and the Space Review was in attendance.

The Review of US Human Space Flight Plans Committee
held their first public meeting in Washington last week.
- The Space Review
"The committee’s first meeting, held last Wednesday at the Carnegie Institute for Science in Washington, DC, appeared to confirm those beliefs. Much of the eight-hour hearing was devoted to examining Constellation and well as several alternative systems that could be ready sooner and/or with less money than the incumbent. And while the committee dropped no hints about what direction it might be leaning, the hearing certainly triggered discussion within and outside the meeting that will last all summer, if not beyond."
Meeting Agendas
- June 17 Public Agenda (pdf, 11k)
Meeting Presentations
- 9:20am - Summary of past studies - NASA/Mike Hawes (pdf, 60k)
- 9:30am - Constellation Program - Nasa/Doug Cooke (pdf, 4.55MB)
- 10:00am - ISS Partner Discussion - ESA - Jean-Jacques Dordain (pdf, 241k)
- 10:00am - ISS Partner Discussion - RSA - Perminov (pdf, 460k)
- 12:00pm - Comments via Website (pdf, 81k)
- 1:00pm - EELV Considerations - NASA Expendable Launch Services Current Use of EELV - Lynn Cline (pdf, 590k)
- 1:00pm - EELV Considerations - Briefing to the Review of U.S. Human Space Flight Plans Committee - Michael Gass (pdf, 3.03MB)
- 1:00pm - EELV Considerations - Initial Summary of Human Rated Delta IV Heavy Study - Gary Pulliam (pdf, 123k)
- 2:00pm - Other Commercial Launch Capabilities - NASA COTS - NASA/Doug Cooke (pdf, 773k)
- 2:00pm - Other Commercial Launch Capabilities - SpaceX COTS - SpaceX (pdf, 3.67MB)
- 2:00pm - Other Commercial Launch Capabilities - Orbital COTS - Orbital (pdf, 3.34MB)
- 2:00pm - Other Commercial Launch Capabilities - ISS CRS - NASA/Mike Suffredini (pdf, 790k)
- 3:30pm - Alternative Architectures - Direct - Steve Metschan (pdf, 26.9MB)
- 3:30pm - Alternative Architectures - Shuttle Side-mount Options - NASA/John Shannon (pdf, 2.35MB)
Friday, June 5, 2009
Griffin’s “exit interview”
Space Politics
Perhaps the most interesting question posed by ASAP is their request for the top five goals for the next administrator, since, as it turns out, ASAP’s membership included the person picked to be the next administrator. Griffin’s response, summarized:
Saturday, May 9, 2009
Augustine & Griffin from Jeff Foust's Archive
Sunday, March 30, 2008
Obama's Empty Space Program
“I grew up on Star Trek,” Obama said.
“I believe in the final frontier.”
Two other Heads-Ups from Foust
...have been posted more than worth reading and pondering:
Upcoming Hearings:
As Congress returns from recess next week, the House Science and Technology Committee has a couple of relevant hearings scheduled. On Wednesday morning, April 2, the research and education subcommittee is holding a hearing on “International Science and Technology Cooperation” with the following witnesses scheduled:
- Dr. John Marburger, Director, Office of Science and Technology Policy
- Dr. Arden Bement, Director, National Science Foundation (NSF)
- Dr. Nina Fedoroff, Science and Technology Advisor to the Secretary, U.S. Department of State
- Mr. Jeff Miotke, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Science, Space and Health, Bureau of Oceans and International and Environmental and Scientific Affairs, U.S. Department of State
- Mr. Michael O’Brien, Assistant Administrator for External Relations, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
On Thursday morning, April 3, the space subcommittee is holding a hearing titled “NASA’s Exploration Initiative: Status and Issues”, with the following witnesses:
- Dr. Richard Gilbrech, Associate Administrator, Exploration Systems Mission Directorate, NASA
- Ms. Cristina T. Chaplain, Director, Acquisition and Sourcing Management,
Government Accountability Office - Dr. Noel Hinners, Independent Consultant
- Dr. Kathryn Thornton, Professor of Department of Science, Technology and Society & Associate Dean of the School of Engineering & Applied Science, University of Virginia
And more from Jeff Foust on the departure of Alan Stern,NASA's former head of the Science Mission Directorate HERE.







