Showing posts with label IKI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IKI. Show all posts

Monday, January 28, 2013

A Russian Moon?

Another design for renewing Russia's groundbreaking program of robotic lunar exploration is set aside. Above is a 2008 notional concept of the Roscosmos Luna-Glob orbiter, equipped with penetrators and supporting both a lander and an ISRO-built rover, part of a highly anticipated international mission recently abandoned. Under the Soviet regime Russia pioneered and brought to an end exploration of the Moon's surface [IKI/Lavochkin].
Dwayne Day
The Space Review

Earlier this month the Russian government announced that it plans to launch a lunar orbiter in 2015, followed by a lander a year later, both of them designated Luna-Glob. This is the latest version of what has been a rather convoluted series of Russian announcements about their planetary exploration plans, particularly with regards to the Moon. Previous plans had involved launching the orbiter and lander together, then changed to launch the lander a year before the orbiter. Now the Russians have switched the order. This is a more logical plan than previous ones, and at least to outsiders it appears as if the Russians are starting to develop a more sensible sequence of planetary science missions, as well as mission goals, than they have in the past. It’s something we should hope for, as the Russians could possibly by the most active nation conducting lunar exploration in the next decade.

Although they have experience with landing robotic craft on the Moon, launching a Moon orbiter before a lander is a better approach for the Russians because they need to re-learn how to walk before they can start to run. In late 2011 they suffered an embarrassing failure of their overly-ambitious Fobos-Grunt mission. The spacecraft fell silent almost immediately after launch, circled the Earth for a few weeks, and finally reentered. Many independent observers had predicted that Fobos-Grunt would fail because it was too complicated for a space program that had not built a planetary spacecraft in over a decade and a half (see “Red moon around a red planet,” The Space Review, November 7, 2011). The only real surprise was that the spacecraft failed so early, probably a sign that Russian quality control and systems engineering are both in bad shape, something that has been reinforced by a series of launch vehicle problems. Russian planetary science plans in recent years appeared to experience the “Christmas Tree” problem that American robotic spacecraft suffered from in the 1980s. This is where a mission gets more and more complex as scientists add more instruments, increasing the cost and the risk that something will go wrong. Fobos-Grunt had this problem in spades and some Russian lunar missions appeared to be succumbing to it as well. A single mission including an orbiter, lander, and rover, some of them from different countries, is very hard to integrate, but until recently such a mission was in Russian lunar plans.

Read the full article at The Space Review, HERE.

Saturday, April 28, 2012

Chandrayaan-II: ISRO Annual Report

Russian Luna Glob lander with ISRO rover segment of Chandrayaan-2 configuration [ISRO/IKI].
According to the just released India Space Research Organisation (ISRO) Annual Report (PDF) plans still call for India's second lunar mission Chandrayaan-2 to consist of an Orbiter and Rover integrated to a Russian lander.

In February published reports confirmed a goal for launching Chandrayaan-2 in 2013 were push back to at least 2014 (See "Chandrayaan-2 may miss 2013 launch date," February 21).

"It is an Indo-Russian collaborative mission," according to the wide-ranging Report. "The scientific objectives of the mission are to further improve our understanding of the origin and evolution of the Moon using instruments on-board an Orbiter together with in-situ analysis of samples and studies of lunar regolith by both remote and direct analysis.

"India and Russia are cooperating to realize a joint unmanned moon mission with India responsible for launch," the Orbiter and Rover and Russia responsible for the Lander. "Significant progress has been made in the past year," according to the Report, "wherein both sides discussed Orbiter-Lander-Rover configuration" and joint mission operations.

"Indian instruments on both the Chandrayaan-2 Orbiter and Rover have been finalized, and both nations are working to launch Chandrayaan-2 in 2014 using India’s GSLV booster.

Chandrayaan-2 Orbiter Craft (OC)

The Chandrayaan-2 Orbiter configuration has been changed from a 12 to 13k design after additions to the payload capacity of India's indigenous Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle (GSLV), enabled by larger propellant tanks.

The Chandrayaan-2 mission outline was revised to inject the vehicle bus into a lower initial orbit (170 X 16980 km) and higher lift-off weight of 3200 kg. Propulsion system has been adapted to increase fuel capacity.

"Other completed activities" related to Chandrayaan-2, according to the Report, were "finalization of electrical and mechanical interfaces, payload interfaces; preliminary design reviews of bus systems; power, attitude control amd telemetry electronics, tracking and command, RF and data handling systems, thermal control upgrades and propulsion."
Prototype testbed of Chandrayaan-2 lunar
rover, August 2010
[ISRO].
Chandrayaan lunar rover

The ISRO Annual Report appears confident tasks related to the development of the Chandrayaan-2 lunar rover that have been completed include configuration of Rover and instrument payload, and Preliminary Design Review of all subsystems on both the Orbiter and Rover. 

A Lunar Terrain Test Facility has been set up at the Maratahalli Campus in Bangalore, an integration and testing facility for spacecraft larger than 4 tons, where testing in micro-gravity and lunar surface simulations will soon begin..

The Chandrayaan-2 Orbiter and Russian-GK Lander Craft (LC) together with the LC and Rover interfaces were finalized this past year in three face-to-face meetings with Russian delegations, "apart from regular mail communication and teleconferences," according to the Annual Report. 

Landing site identification "has been initiated," and future workflow schedules "have been "worked out."

Monday, April 9, 2012

Russian Academy plans Lunokhod-3 and 4

Schematic representation of the Luna-LD-Rover concept, as presented to the Lunar Exploration Analysis Group (LEAG) annual meeting in 2010. The overall robust rover and experiments, designed for long-duration exploration through several lunar days and nights, builds on the successful Lunokhod scenarios [Institute for Space Research - Moscow].
The Russian Academy of Sciences has prepared early plans for two Lunokhod-class unmanned lunar rovers, "Lunokhod 3 and Lunokhod-4," to “work the Moon” between 2020 and 2023, this according to a document obtained by the news agency RIA Novosti. A stationary “landing station” is pegged for 2024 “as the first steps to form the future manned lunar base” sometime later.

As the heart of the Soviet Union, Russia was the first and only nation to deploy unmanned rovers on the Moon, Lunokhod-1 in 1970 and Lunokhod-2 in 1973.

Russia completed the last soft landing and sample-return mission on the Moon, Luna 24, in 1976.

The Luna-Glob polar lander, together with its Russian orbiter, originally planned for 2012, and the Luna Resurs polar lander, with India's Chandrayaan-2 orbiter and mini-rover were planned for 2013. Set backs caused by systemic problems, highly manifested in the Phobos-Grunt failure, have resulted in a national reexamination of Russia's unmanned and manned space exploration plans, beyond participation in the International Space Station [IKI].
Missions originally developed for 2012 and 2013, Luna-Resurs and Luna-Glob, are apparently to be pushed back to after 2015. Whether India will continue to participate in those early missions is a question still up in the air. In February the India Space Research Organisation (ISRO) postponed indefinitely the Chandrayaan-2 lunar orbiter and rover combination. India’s rover was designed to be ferried to the surface on Luna-Resurs.

“Under the document," obtained by RIA Novosti, core aims of the Russian scientists are to study polar regions of the Moon and gas-dust exosphere,” according to the April 7 news account. An overall goal of the Academy is to collect samples “and find the most comfortable areas for lunar base deployment.

“The lunar rovers and the landing station will form first elements of space infrastructure for a lunar testing area with prospects of deployment of Russia’s lunar base.”

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

LRO LEND: "A Scientific Dispute"

Uncollimated (top) and collimated (below) views of
the Moon from the LEND instrument. From “What
is the LEND collimated detector really measuring,
”
Eke et al., 43rd Lunar and Planetary Science
Conference (2012), #2211.
Paul D. Spudis
The Once and Future Moon
Smithsonian Air & Space
 
Attendees at the recently concluded 43rd annual Lunar and Planetary Science Conference had front row seats to a heated debate on new data from the Moon.  As opposed to how many envision scientific debate – coolly logical, white-frocked intellectuals, dispassionately discussing points of contention in a laboratory – what they witnessed was an impassioned and stormy exchange of differing opinions.  There is good reason for passion.  Subsequent decisions based on these data places the success or failure of future missions in the crosshairs.

Point in question: a team of scientists on NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) mission claim that their new neutron mapping shows that locations of high hydrogen content are not well correlated with dark areas near the poles of the Moon.  This relation seems to contradict (at least, it is not consistent with) one of the key concepts about water at the poles of the Moon – that it occurs in dark polar cold traps, where water is stable on the surface and cannot be ejected from the Moon (as appears to be the case for most water deposited there).

This new idea is current because LRO carries something called a collimated neutron spectrometer, named the Lunar Exploration Neutron Detector (LEND), an instrument provided to NASA by IKI, the Space Research Institute of the Russian Academy of Science.  NASA flew a neutron spectrometer to the Moon over 10 years ago on a global mapping mission called Lunar Prospector (LP).  That instrument had an omni-directional (4-pi) field-of-view (FOV), meaning that it simultaneously looked in all directions.  As such, the resolution of features on the surface made by this instrument was fairly low, being effectively equal to the altitude of the spacecraft.  The LP neutron mapping spectrometer obtained a best resolution of about 30 km, meaning that any smaller feature could not be resolved in the FOV of the detector.  Unfortunately, most of the dark, cold areas near the poles are smaller than this.  LP detected enhanced levels of hydrogen in both polar regions, but couldn’t detect whether these hydrogen reservoirs were confined to the permanently shadowed areas, thus increasing the likelihood that the hydrogen was in the form of water.

In order to identify zones of high hydrogen content and determine if they were truly associated with the cold, dark areas, as predicted by theory, scientists wanted higher resolution maps of the poles for the next mission to the Moon.  The way to obtain higher resolution is to restrict the field of view of the neutron instrument to where it looks only at a small spot directly below the orbiter.  This involves putting a shield on the detector (called a collimator) that restricts the FOV to the lunar surface only; this technique can resolve areas on the surface smaller than the orbital altitude during mapping.  A drawback to using a collimator is that restricting the FOV means that the flux, or total number of neutrons that can be detected per unit time, is much lower, which greatly reduces precision of the measurements.  However, the longer the counting is conducted, the more precise the data.  LRO was to remain in lunar orbit for at least a two-year mission; it has now been orbiting the Moon and collecting data for almost three years.

Over the last year, the LEND team’s reports have appeared in the scientific literature.  To the surprise of most lunar scientists, their team claimed that in all but two or three isolated cases, hydrogen detected by LEND does not correlate with the polar dark areas.  This puzzling result would seem to indicate that perhaps we do not fully understand the nature of the polar hydrogen and the processes involved in their creation and retention.

Thus the debate commenced at last Monday’s scientific session, when several scientists (I will collectively call them the “skeptics”) who work with neutron data from LP and other missions, differed with the LEND team conclusions, who in turn vigorously defended their results as valid, citing as evidence the coincidence of laser altimetry and neutron data over one crater (Shoemaker) near the south pole of the Moon.  Having studied the LEND data set themselves, the skeptics contended that the actual average count rate for neutrons is less than half of that quoted by the LEND team, meaning that the hydrogen content inferred from the LEND data are significantly less precise than claimed.  Moreover, they estimate that the signal from the collimated (high resolution) detectors is only a few percent of the total signal, whereas the LEND team claims that it is roughly one-third of the total.  The skeptics make the point that if the collimator is working as the LEND team claim, the map derived from the collimated detector should be a sharper, higher resolution version of the low-resolution map made in the uncollimated mode.  In fact, the skeptics contend that the two maps look completely different (see figure at top of this post), suggesting that the collimated product is detecting something else; based on the observed pattern, it is probably related to the amount of iron in the lunar surface.

This is not some arcane, academic dispute.  We will depend on the mapping results from LRO to identify potential landing sites for future missions, including the selection of the most hydrogen-rich areas for exploration and possible future utilization.  Such decisions could involve the expenditure of hundreds of millions of dollars, so there is some pressure to make the correct ones.

So where does this impasse leave the lunar science community?  Mostly befuddled.  The vast majority of scientists simply do not have the time to read every scientific paper published, especially in fields peripheral to their own interests.  However, in the course of their research, scientists often find that they must decide what to believe about uncertain or controversial ideas that may relate to their own studies.  Is there a correct way to decide which interpretation to believe?  After a quick and cursory review of the competing concepts, most scientists will adopt the majority, or “consensus” viewpoint.  If they know someone with relevant expertise, they may ask for and rely on the considered judgment of that expert.  Few scientists are able to read and make their own considered judgments about a field in which they have little understanding or no expertise.  Thus, they tend to choose their position on the basis of non-scientific evaluations of the technical credibility of those arguing for or against a given viewpoint.

In this case, the detailed distribution of hydrogen at the poles of the Moon remains unclear.  While both LP and LEND uncollimated (e.g., omni-directional) maps appear nearly identical, the collimated LEND polar hydrogen maps show widely varying concentrations, with little coherence over short distances.  Repeatability of measurement is important in science.  The fact that two completely different instruments on two different missions found nearly identical results suggests that the low resolution, uncollimated LP and LEND maps are currently the best reflection of reality we have.  These uncollimated data most likely will remain the polar hydrogen maps of choice by working lunar scientists.

Originally published March 27, 2012 at his Smithsonian Air & Space blog The Once and Future Moon, Dr. Spudis is a senior staff scientist at the Lunar and Planetary Institute. The opinions expressed are those of the author and are better informed than average.

Related Post: Will LRO LEND prove ineffective? (February 21, 2012)